If you buy gold that someone else stores for you, the most important question is not the price per ounce but what you actually own. Allocated vs unallocated gold is the distinction that answers it. With allocated gold, specific bars are set aside as your property. With unallocated gold, you hold a claim on the provider for an amount of gold, and the provider owns the metal. The difference only becomes visible if something goes wrong, which is exactly why it is worth understanding before you buy.

What is the difference between allocated and unallocated gold?

Allocated gold is backed by identified bars that belong to you, held by a custodian on your behalf. Unallocated gold is an entitlement to a quantity of gold, recorded as a balance, while the provider keeps ownership of the metal. In the words of the London Bullion Market Association, an unallocated holder has “a contractual claim” rather than a specific bar.

How allocated gold works

When you hold allocated gold, particular bars are recorded against your name. The LBMA describes allocated accounts as being backed by a specific bar, with the holder receiving a weight list that shows each bar’s unique number, its gross weight and its fineness. The custodian looks after the metal but does not own it, so it should not form part of the custodian’s own assets.

That structure removes most of the credit risk. The LBMA puts it plainly: with an allocated account, “the investor does not have a credit exposure” to the institution that keeps the account. If the custodian ran into financial trouble, your bars should still be yours, although recovering them could still take time and paperwork.

You will see two versions of allocated storage. In segregated storage your bars are kept physically apart from everyone else’s. In non-segregated or pooled allocated storage, bars are held in a shared area but each bar is still recorded to a named owner. Both give you title to specific metal. Segregated storage usually costs more.

How unallocated gold works

An unallocated account works much like a bank balance measured in ounces. No individual bars are assigned to you. The provider owes you a quantity of gold and may hold, lend or trade its own metal as its terms allow. The LBMA describes unallocated holdings as the most common way metal is held and settled in the wholesale market, and gives the reason in one word: convenience. Buying, selling and moving balances is quick and cheap because nothing physical has to change hands.

The cost of that convenience is credit risk. Because you are a creditor rather than an owner, your position depends on the provider staying solvent and honouring its obligations. If it failed, you would normally rank as an unsecured creditor for the value of your gold, not as the owner of particular bars.

Allocated vs unallocated gold side by side

Allocated

  • You own specific, numbered bars
  • A weight list identifies your metal
  • No credit exposure to the custodian
  • Storage and insurance fees apply
  • Smallest holding is usually a whole bar, or a share of pooled bars

Unallocated

  • You hold a claim for an amount of gold
  • The provider owns the metal
  • You depend on the provider’s solvency
  • Usually a lower account fee
  • Easy to buy and sell in small amounts

How the fees differ

Both arrangements cost money to hold. The LBMA notes that investors pay a storage fee for an allocated account or a maintenance fee for an unallocated one, often expressed as a small percentage of the value of the metal and charged periodically. Allocated storage tends to cost more because the custodian has to store, insure and audit identifiable bars. Unallocated holdings can be cheaper because the provider has more freedom with the metal.

When comparing providers, add up every charge: the dealing spread when you buy, the annual storage or account fee, insurance, any fee to take delivery, and the spread when you sell. A low storage fee can be offset by a wide spread. Our guide to whether gold is a good investment explains how these costs eat into a return over time.

Where ETCs, digital gold and coins fit

Physically backed exchange-traded commodities hold bullion with a custodian, but you own a security issued by the product, not bars of your own. Read the product documents to see whether the metal is held on an allocated basis and who the custodian is.

Online “vaulted gold” and app-based gold accounts vary widely. Some give you title to allocated metal, even in fractions of a bar. Others are unallocated, or give you only a contractual right. The marketing will not always say which, so check the terms and conditions for the words “allocated”, “title” and “bar list”.

Coins and small bars you keep yourself avoid custodian risk completely, but you take on storage, insurance and security instead. Our guide to buying gold coins as an investment looks at that trade-off, and our comparison of gold bars and gold coins covers the practical and tax differences.

Questions to ask a gold storage provider

Ask, in writing, whether your gold is allocated or unallocated, and whether allocated storage is segregated or pooled. Ask whether you will receive a bar list or certificate, how often holdings are independently audited and whether audit results are published. Find out who the vault operator and insurer are, and whether the insurance covers the full value of client metal. Check what happens to your gold if the provider stops trading, how and when you can sell, and whether you can take physical delivery and at what cost.

It is also worth checking what protection applies. Buying and storing physical gold is generally not a regulated investment activity in the UK, so the FSCS and the Financial Ombudsman Service are unlikely to help if a dealer or storage company fails. That makes the ownership structure, and the strength of the business behind it, more important rather than less.

Which suits you?

If your main reason for holding gold is protection against financial stress, allocated storage fits that purpose better, because it does not rely on the provider’s balance sheet. If you trade often in small amounts and value low cost and convenience, an unallocated account may be acceptable, provided you understand the credit risk you are taking. Whichever you choose, the allocated vs unallocated gold question should be answered clearly before you hand over any money. You can compare gold options in one place on our gold investment page.

This article is general information, not financial advice. The gold price can fall as well as rise, your capital is at risk, and past performance is not a guide to future returns.